Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Problems Today That is Fixed In 'The Giver'

Well a major problem in this world is overpopulation. Now some people may think that overpopulation is a good thing because more people are born. It's not. Overpopulation is actually causing another problem: starvation. Since more and more people are coming into this world, more food needs to be consumed. Some people are hunting a lot more than they need. This is driving the animals to extinction, and will eventually lead to ours. Food is getting more and more scarce when someone is born, and not to mention some of our food is also the food animals eat too.

In the book 'The Giver' by Lois Lowry, they live in a community where many of the problems that exist in our world are gone forever. One of these fixed problems is the one I was talking about earlier: overpopulation and starvation. In the community, there are different jobs that each person must take called assignments. One of these assignments is called 'birthmother'. This assignment is about females giving birth to a maximum of three children, then become workers. Since not every female can be a birthmother, this is a system to maintain the population, thus meaning that food can be equally distributed, and everyone's happy. Since babies are born usually by an act of love (don't comment on that), which is solved by a pill that stops what they call, 'stirrings'. People that start to fall in love with someone has to take the stirrings pill to erase that feeling, and families are assigned, not made by a blood relationship.

Here's my thought about this solution. Ok, so yes I understand that overpopulation is very bad, and starvation is even worse. I have no objections to the job of birthmother having three babies and then becoming workers. The stirrings pill also erases problems like sexual assaults (rape), which is great, because that's also a problem solved. But the idea of no actual love is kind of disturbing. In our world, we don't stay with someone because we're told to, we stay with them because we want to. Being in an assigned family is good because the population won't increase, but the idea of staying with someone just because we are told to is an idea I don't really like. These problems are like all things in this world. Solving them is never perfect. Everything has it's pros and cons.

1 comment:

mjh said...

You did a good job with this, Edric, linking overpopulation to starvation. You've identified their method of solving the problem as well, but in the end you cheated me out of knowing what your real feelings were. You didn't take a definite stand. WHAT DO YOU THINK?